Personal Identity

"Personal identity consists not in the sameness of substance, but in the sameness of a continued consciousness."

— John Locke

Today's Question

What makes you feel that you and your self from 10 years ago are 'the same person' — is it memory, or some unchanged trait?

If a prince and a cobbler swapped bodies, where would 'you' be?

John Locke, an empiricist who believed the mind begins as a blank slate, redefined personal identity itself: not a fixed soul, but a stream of consciousness held together by memory.

In his 'Essay Concerning Human Understanding,' he argued that if a prince's consciousness were transferred into a cobbler's body, people would still call that body 'the cobbler' — but the consciousness carrying the prince's memories would be the real prince. In other words, 'you' reside wherever your memory continues, not wherever your body is.

Write Your Answer in the App